Council backs HRB’s denial of request to demolish East John Fitch home
By JIM BROOKS
Nelson County Gazette
Councilman Joe Buckman gestures while discussing the appeal by Thomas M. and Lana Brackett of an HRB ruling that denied their request to demolish a home at 111 East John Fitch.
Wednesday, July 3, 2013, 3 a.m. — In a split 4-2 split decision, the Bardstown City Council voted Tuesday to uphold the decision by the Historic Review Board that denied Thomas M. and Lana Brackett’s request to demolish a home located at 111 East John Fitch Ave.
The Bracketts requested permission from the Historic Review Board (HRB) to demolish the home based on its deteriorated condition. The council’s vote Tuesday night upheld the HRB’s May 21, 2013, unanimous decision to deny the Brackett’s demolition request.
Danny Reid, owner of Reid’s Plumbing, attended the public hearing Tuesday in the city council chambers, stating that he would like to purchase the property and build a new home on the lot.
During the hearing, Thomas Brackett explained how the home’s condition has worsened since he purchased it in 2003. Michael Coen, the attorney representing the HRB, said the HRB’s findings support their determination the house is worthy of preservation, even if the rear wing is demolished.
Councilman John Royalty make a point during the discussion of the HRB ruling that denied Thomas M. and Lana Brackett’s request to demolish a home at 111 East john Fitch Ave.
Councilman Joe Buckman told the council he believed the home had historic value, particularly in light of its importance in local African-American history.
Councilman John Royalty agreed with the Brackett’s assertion the home was too far gone to make it economically feasible to repair. Councilman Francis Lydian argued there was likely hidden damage that prior inspections were unable to find.
Mayor Bill Sheckles reminded the council the real question was if they council was willing to support its own historic zoning ordinances and the work of the HRB.
Councilmen Bobby Simpson, Tommy Reed, Roland Williams and Joe Buckman voted to deny the Brackett’s appeal of the HRB ruling, while Royalty and Lydian voted in favor of the Brackett’s appeal.
-30-
